Barbato's - Supreme Review


Price at Purchase: $10.95 + tax
Size/Diameter/Slices: Medium / 12"/8
Description: Medium pizza with extra cheese, pepperoni, green peppers, onions, and mushrooms
What We Liked:  The amount of toppings was pretty good for a supreme.  The extra cheese was very flavorful and the other toppings were spread evenly over this pie.  That includes both onions (not my favorite) and mushrooms (not Jen's favorite).  The crust was fresh, which is good, but wasn't our favorite.
What We Didn’t Like: Although the crust was fresh, it was also very greasy and unfortunately it was fairly chewy as well.  It didn't have the light, fluffy, crispy taste that we've found in other pizzas.  One of Jen's pet peeves are vegetables that are cooked before going onto the pizza.  Barbato's does this and as a result the toppings, especially the onions and green peppers weren't full of flavor and lacked the "crunch" that makes fresh vegetables good.
Overall:  Barbato's is another famous local chain that has four locations across Erie.  Although I personally love their subs, this first pizza fell a little flat for both of us.  Although the supreme comes with a lot of toppings, the vegetables were cooked and the crust was chewy and greasy.  While the pizza wasn't bad, there wasn't anything special to make it stand out.  As average as it gets.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Southgate Pizza East - "White Pizza" w/Chicken, Tomato, Onion

Image
Price at Purchase: $10.50 + tax Size/Diameter/Slices: Medium / 12"/8 Description: Medium "white pizza" with chicken, tomato, and onion What We Liked:   To be honest, we liked almost everything about this pizza.  Not only was the freshly made dough consistent and flavorful, all the ingredients really popped.  I first noticed how much cheese there was, which I enjoyed.  The tomatoes and onions tasted very good, were fresh, and again complemented the rest of the pizza.  The chicken was fully cooked, but still tender.  We would comment on the "white pizza" aspect here, but we can't...which leads me into the next section... What We Didn’t Like:  Unfortunately...this wasn't a white pizza!  Traditionally a white pizza is devoid of pizza sauce, and has a good amount of olive oil, salt, and herbs.  There was definitely pizza sauce here, and we didn't notice any additional herbs sprinkled on the top.  Jen had wished she added some fresh basil to
Read more

Lucchetti's - Custom Order Review

Image
  Price at Purchase: $14.30 including tax Size/Diameter/Slices: Medium / 12"/8 Description: Medium pizza with 1/2 meatballs and green peppers; 1/2 sausage and onions What We Liked:   We were pretty impressed with this restaurant. The service was great, especially considering we placed this order on a holiday when most other local pizzerias were closed. The crust was made with fresh dough and the vegetables were also fresh (not pre-cooked). The sausage was a bit spicy (this is a good thing in my opinion) and the meatballs are homemade. There were a lot of toppings on the pizza and the sauce was very tomato-ey. What We Didn’t Like:  The crust on the pizza is a bit on the thin and crispy side, which was very good, but a little too crispy for my taste. We ordered a two-topping pizza; however, since we split the pizza in half (two different toppings on each side), we're pretty sure they charged us for four toppings instead. The guy working mentioned they would be comi
Read more

Barbato's - Chicken Bruschetta Review

Image
Price at Purchase: $10.95 + tax Size/Diameter/Slices: Medium / 12"/8 Description: Medium pizza with chicken, tomatoes, mozzarella, and butter garlic sauce What We Liked:   It was nice to try something different, as our usual orders consist of supremes and custom orders with sausage and pepperoni. This pizza had plenty of cheese, chicken and tomatoes and tons of flavor from the buttery/garlicky sauce. The tomatoes were fresh, the grilled chicken was tender and the crust was soft and chewy and crispy on the outside (fresh dough). What We Didn’t Like:  I tricked myself into believing this would be a healthier version of the pizzas we typically order... not the case. This pizza was super greasy from the excess butter & garlic sauce. It tasted great, sure, but it was literally dripping with butter. I chose the patented napkin-dabbing method in order to minimize my fat/calorie consumption for the day, but not sure how much it helped. Overall:   We also ordered this ve
Read more