Yum Yum's - Supreme Review

Price at Purchase: $12.75 + tax
Size/Diameter/Slices: Regular / 12"/8
Description: Regular pizza with pepperoni, sausage, ham, meatball, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and banana peppers (yuck)

What We Liked:  Advertised on their menu, the fresh crust was pretty good, and we think they may have added some garlic butter for extra flavor.  There wasn't a whole lot of texture, but at the same time it wasn't chewy.  There were a lot of toppings on the pizza, almost to a fault, but there should've been given the high cost of this pie.  Also, there was a good amount of cheese behind the mounds of toppings.

What We Didn’t Like: One of Jen's pet peeves returns in the form of pre-cooked vegetables.  While this wasn't a huge deterrent to me, I do notice quite a difference as the toppings were "soggy" rather than crunchy.  As mentioned, the large amount of toppings actually led to the cheese sliding off the crust when choosing a piece, which is an annoyance but not a true negative.  In addition, 12.75 for, let's call a spade a spade, a medium is pretty high.  Also, we chose to do carry out, and the pizza wasn't ready for nearly 40 minutes!  That's quite a wait time for a pick-up order.

Overall:  Well, this is another first for us.  I've personally driven past Yum Yum's for many years and never given it a chance.  This pizza was good, but ultimately didn't stand out for us as being one of the better pies we've tasted recently.  The pre-cooked vegetables, soft crust, high price, and long waiting time put us off.  This first experience wasn't great, but we're still looking forward to future orders from this pizzeria.